Is Rye better or Bourbon for a classic NYC Old Fashioned?

Bourbon vs Rye in a Manhattan What's the Difference?

Old-Fashioned Recipe - NYT Cooking

The sweet, caramelly flavors suggest a high-rye Bourbon. Expect bold almond, oak, brown butter and pecan pie flavors. The drying baking-spice finish

Knob Creek Rye

Cocktail Crate - Old Fashioned, 375 ml – Viski

15 Best Whiskies to Use in an Old Fashioned

World Class Whiskey - From Vermont?

The Best Whiskeys for an Old Fashioned — The Three Drinkers

The 10 Best Bourbons You Can Buy in 2023

The 11 Best Rye Whiskeys You Can Buy in 2023